Can You Appeal the Outcome of a Family Court Ruling?

Jordan Meggs • Jul 17, 2023

Unpacking Appeals in Alabama's Family Law: A guide to understanding your rights, navigating timelines, and maximizing legal support for favorable outcomes.

Divorced parents look to appeal custody ruling

Family law is a difficult field. When you get embroiled in a contested divorce, child custody battle, or child protective services case, it can feel like all the cards are stacked against you. Thankfully, every Alabama resident has rights as well as responsibilities when it comes to family law. One of them is the right to obtain legal counsel in the form of a family court lawyer. Another is the right to appeal.


What Is an Appeal?


As in other legal fields, an appeal in a family court offers an opportunity to raise concerns about specific errors that occurred during litigation. In the context of divorce and child custody issues, parties that disagree with judges' rulings can move to vacate, amend, or alter them. If a trial court issues a divorce order, that order can also be appealed. Alabama laws refer to the person filing an appeal as an appellant and the other party as a respondent.


Grounds for Appeals in Family Law


The fact that you don't agree with a judge's decision doesn't necessarily mean that it can be appealed successfully. If you want to have a higher court review an issue related to the divorce, you'll need to prove to the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals that the trial court abused its discretion. In other words, you have grounds for appeal only if the trial judge misinterpreted the facts of the case or incorrectly applied the higher court's laws or legal precedents.


Reasons to File an Appeal


Family court appeals are fairly commonplace because it is rarely the case that both parties walk away from a contested divorce feeling satisfied. Most appeals relate to child custody or support. However, divorce orders related to alimony, division of assets, or other issues are also grounds for appeal if the appellant can prove that they occurred as a result of a failure to consider all the facts or apply the law correctly.


Timelines for Filing an Appeal


If you want to file an appeal, you should take action as quickly as possible. You can ask to vacate, alter, or amend a court ruling by filing a Rule 59 motion within 30 days. Appellants appealing a trial court's divorce order have 42 days to file a Notice of Appeal. Once these deadlines have passed, you will forfeit your right to appeal.


What to Expect


Family court appeals don't result in new trials. Instead of re-examining evidence or reinterviewing witnesses, the higher court will simply check the record to determine whether the lower court judge misinterpreted the facts or incorrectly applied the higher court's laws. Your lawyer will also submit a written brief that explains the facts and legal points that support the appeal. You must serve the brief on the respondent in addition to filing it with the Appellate Division.


You shouldn't assume that the Court of Appeals focusing on issues with the application of the law rather than the facts of the case means that all matters of fact are excluded. If you have uncovered new, relevant facts during the period following the court order, you should include them in the appeal. The higher court will consider them during its review of the application, and they may impact how the court rules on the case. This process is referred to as modifying a decree.


Following the court's review of the original record and your written summary, the respondent will file a brief. You can also submit a brief in reply. Because of the complexity of these proceedings and the fact that all five judges on the Alabama Court of Appeals must review the relevant information, it can take several months to receive an opinion on the case. 


Alternatives to Filing an Appeal


Filing an appeal can be time-consuming and expensive, so it's not always the best solution. You may also want to ask your lawyer about other viable alternatives that might fit the situation. Other options include:


  • Requests to vacate a court judgment
  • Requests for reconsideration of an order
  • Filing for a new trial


In these cases, it may be possible to introduce new facts or change the legal strategy. You should also note that filing a Notice of Appeal will not automatically stop a court order from going into effect. To do that, you'll also have to apply for a stay. If granted, it will delay the court order from going into effect for a short period.


How to Appeal DHR Decisions


So far, this article has focused only on appealing divorce orders related to child custody, child support, or alimony. However, family courts also hear cases regarding child abuse and neglect brought by the Department of Human Resources (DHR). The state's Administrative Procedures Act details the requirements for challenging DHR administrative decisions. According to Ala. Code 41-22-20, you must file a notice of appeal with the circuit court that:


  1. Identifies you as the aggrieved party.
  2. Identifies the decision the court will need to review.
  3. Provides sufficient information to DHR regarding the requested judicial review of its decision.


As with divorce order appeals, you must file DHR appeals within 30 days of receiving the agency's final decision. In addition to the Notice of Appeal, you will need to file a petition that details the DHR's decision and why the court should review it. While you can't submit any new facts or information when seeking judicial review of a contested case, you can introduce evidence of misconduct or fraud regarding DHR personnel or point out procedural irregularities not contained in the official record.


The Importance of Hiring a Lawyer


If you plan to appeal, you should seek legal representation right away. A family law attorney can help you understand the available legal options, compose a brief, and meet all relevant deadlines. Whether you want a circuit court to review a DHR decision, appeal a trial court's divorce order, or file a Rule 59 motion, the process will go more smoothly with the help of a lawyer.


By Nik Fondren 09 May, 2024
Staying Secure: Navigating Privacy and Reputation Management During Divorce
By Nik Fondren 09 May, 2024
Exploring Paths to Parenthood: A Guide to the Various Adoption Processes
By Nik Fondren 08 May, 2024
Maximizing Impact: Strategies for Integrating Philanthropy into Your Estate Plans
By Nik Fondren 10 Apr, 2024
Methods to Prepare for Life's Biggest Decisions
By Nik Fondren 10 Apr, 2024
Protecting Your Assets and Your Loved Ones
By Nik Fondren 10 Apr, 2024
Nobody wants to be stopped by the police, even when they have done nothing wrong. If you are in this situation, knowing what to do can help reduce the stress associated with this encounter. Stay calm and never act hostile toward the officers. Know your rights and what to do so the situation doesn’t escalate. Know Your Rights Most people know they have the right to remain silent during an encounter with law enforcement. You may be required to provide your name, depending on state laws where the encounter occurs, but that is it. Firmly state you wish to remain silent and stop speaking. They cannot compel you to do so once you make this statement. Furthermore, if police stop you while driving, the right to remain silent applies to any passengers in the vehicle. Passengers might also ask if they can leave during this traffic stop. If officers say they may, they should do so quietly. The Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution prohibits unreasonable searches and seizures. Law enforcement officers cannot search your person, home, or car without your permission unless they have a warrant. Have them produce this warrant so you can review it. However, officers may pat you down to check for weapons. They are permitted to do so for their safety. If the officers ask to search, say that you do not consent. They may conduct this search anyway, depending on the circumstances of the encounter. This verbal statement that you do not consent to the search may become important if authorities file charges against you. When officers enter the home, they may not search without your permission or a search warrant. If they arrest you at home or work, they have the right to search the immediate area or anywhere they can see criminal activity. Pay attention to what they do throughout this search to confirm they conduct it properly and don’t overstep their bounds. Every person has a right to a criminal defense attorney in Cullman, AL . Request a government-appointed attorney if you cannot afford to hire a lawyer. Let the officers know you would like to make a phone call. They cannot listen to any calls between you and an attorney, but they have the right to listen to all other calls you make. The officers can tell you how to request a government-appointed attorney if one is needed. Handling Police Encounters Safely During any encounter with the police, stay calm. Never volunteer information, even if it seems harmless. Use your right to remain silent or only answer direct questions, never offering additional information when doing so. Never argue with officers or bad-mouth them, as doing so could change the whole tone of the interaction. If officers attempt to pull you over while you are driving, continue operating the vehicle until you reach a place where it is safe to stop. Never stop in the middle of the road or impede traffic, as doing so puts you and the officer at risk of harm. When the vehicle is stopped, remain in the car, turn on the interior light, and put your hands where the officer may see them. Ask passengers in the vehicle to show their hands as well. Provide any documents requested by the officer during this traffic stop. They may ask to see your driver’s license, registration, and proof of insurance. Before collecting these documents, let the officer know where they are located. Reaching into a glove box or under the seat may appear to be a threatening move to the officer. Letting them know that is where the documents are and that you aren’t reaching for a weapon can help to reduce tension. Never run from a police officer. Also, do not touch the officers, as any touch could be construed as threatening in a volatile situation. If officers arrest you, go willingly. Don’t resist or become combative. Doing so could make a bad situation worse. Common Misconceptions People often believe they must consent to a search or take a breathalyzer test. They feel they are required to answer questions when asked by law enforcement. A person doesn’t have to say or do anything when stopped by the police. Failing to answer questions or consent to a search may result in a trip to the police station. Let this happen and contact an attorney with your one phone call. While the trip to the station is an inconvenience, it will probably be a short-lived one once your attorney arrives. They will work to get the matter resolved and have you released quickly. Protecting the Rights of Others You may find yourself in a situation where law enforcement is handling a matter involving another individual and you are merely a bystander. Help each other out by observing this interaction and recording it if possible. Try to capture officers’ badges and patrol car numbers with the video to show who was involved beyond what can be seen in the video. Also, ask witnesses to state their names and contact information on the video. They may need to share what they saw with authorities. If the situation is mishandled in any way, contact the internal affairs department of the law enforcement agency, so they may handle the matter. In addition, share the video with the attorneys of all parties involved in the interaction if problems arise. When law enforcement officers know they will be held accountable for their actions, fewer problems typically arise during a stop or other interaction. Law enforcement officers cannot stop bystanders from recording their interactions with individuals. However, the person taking the video must not interfere with police activity in any way. If you wish to record an interaction, do so from a safe distance. Don’t hide the fact you are recording, as police officers know they do not have any expectations of privacy while on the job. However, you may need to ask those interacting with the officers if they wish to be recorded. State laws vary on whether permission is needed so it is always better to ask. A person may come into contact with law enforcement multiple times throughout their life. All parties are responsible for what happens in each interaction. Know your rights and how to handle these interactions safely and legally. Everyone must work together to keep our country safe while ensuring our rights remain protected. This is not a job for one person alone.
By Nik Fondren 07 Feb, 2024
Selecting the Right Executor: Essential Tips for Your Will
By Nik Fondren 07 Feb, 2024
Ensure your Journey Through Divorce is as Smooth as Possible
By Nik Fondren 07 Feb, 2024
Steps to Take to Ensure your Family's Security
By Nik Fondren 07 Feb, 2024
Finding the Right Path to Take When Your Marriage Comes to a Close
More Posts
Share by: